vs

New Relic vs. Instana Comparison

Which is the best observability solution for you?
Written by
Louis-Victor Jadavji, Cofounder of Taloflow

Who should you choose and why?

âś‹ Most important consideration

  • If you want to work with an open platform that supports open source third-party agents (i.e., OTEL/Prometheus) and may want to switch your observability stack in the future, New Relic offers a lot more flexibility.

🤔 Strongly consider New Relic over Instana if

  • You prefer an open platform that supports open source third-party agents (i.e., OTEL/Prometheus).

🤔 Strongly consider Instana over New Relic if

  • If you want to do any kind of code profiling, New Relic doesn't have good support. Code profiling provides the insights to improve code efficiency and debug more effectively.
  • If you want real-time metrics. Instana is the only APM vendor that offers visible metrics in the user interface in under 1 second, or practically real-time.
  • If you want better dependency mapping. Instana has a relationship engine that automatically calculates the relationships and dependencies for each unit of work.
  • If you have purely microservices-based architecture.
  • You want fully dynamic instrumentation where you barely have to worry much about the frameworks and other tools that developers are using (i.e., language independent), Instana has an outsized advantage.
  • You want a more effective tool for automated problem resolution.

đź“ť Other Notes

  • Instana has a relatively cheaper solution for most use cases, but New Relic's unique data consumption based pricing model can be a lot cheaper for some.

We put all the information below in an interactive quiz to make your APM and observability provider choice easy.

Get my free observability evaluation
It takes 5 minutes

“Gotchas”

Feature Comparison

Feature

Use Case Fit

Problem Resolution

Pricing

Observability

Instrumentation

Integration With Other Services

Not all observability providers have the integrations or compatibility with tools and languages like Rancher, AlertOps, or Rust.



Compliance Requirements

Compliance with standards like PCI DSS, HIPAA, ISO 27001, FedRAMP and more have been tracked and recorded.



About the Author

Louis-Victor Jadavji

Louis-Victor Jadavji (or "LV") is a recognized leader in the cloud services industry. He's helped 50+ digital native companies like ModusBox, Later, and NS1 choose the right cloud stack for their applications. His work has been featured in Forbes (30 Under 30 All-Star), HuffPost, The New York Times, The Globe and Mail, and Inc. Magazine.

Read more

Make your systems observable, prioritize using over 1000 data points, and get a transparent report.

Get my free observability evaluation
Best pricing
Stack integration
Feature trade-offs
Reviewed quarterly
David Wilson | CFO at NS1
“Taloflow's buying insights allow us to find and compare new products with technical rigor”

Disclaimer: Taloflow does not guarantee the accuracy of any information on this page including (but not limited to) information about 3rd party software, product pricing, product features, product compliance standards, and product integrations. All product and company names and logos are trademarks™ or registered® trademarks of their respective holders. Use of them does not imply any affiliation or endorsement. Vendor views are not represented in any of our sites, content, research, questionnaires, or reports.